87 replies to this topic

[cph]

I didn't wanted to post this,
as there was a huge commotion from korean Sones...
although I find it a little disturbing,
it's just a comic, where is everyone's sense of humor?
well anyway, the author apologized already.
so before you get this from other sites...

[ak6c]

Yeah, I just read this comic strip a while ago too. Seems like a few SNSD fans were upset about this and wrote negative replies for it and all. >_>;; last member as a 'scribble mark' lol

[grandma deer]

oooo I saw this all over naver, daum, yahoo etc and was wondering what it was about!

[nadyoung]

I saw this comic too. I was wondering what it was about since there were many articles (?) about it. LOL, scribble mark? xD

[CharmedPotat]

I understand why there's so much controversy over this. Look, he wrote '5 bad copies' to represent 5 members, and then a dot for the last member. I wonder who they are, and why he drew them the way they are.

Yes, it's just a comic, but the person who drew it should know the limit to 'disrespecting' the girls.

[MavericK]

I admit it, I laughed.

But wait til he finally discovers the awesomeness that is Taeyeon, then there is no going back. :taeyeon:

Edited by MavericK, 24 January 2009 - 02:23 AM.

[Anny]

ah lol "bad copies"
I don't think the other are bad copies at all >.>
ahwells, that's that guy's opinion
thanks for sharing though ~

[teddybear67]

lol i dont even understand this comic strip . 5 bad copies? O_O
it certainly did not make a negative impact on me

[ChuE]

That is pretty offensive, why would someone do a comic strip like that, it is so disrepsectful to the girls and the group. I think all 9 girls looks beautiful... everyone of them is unique and are what makes them snsd.

I also dont get what the "dot" represents as well, anyone care to clarify what it means? I at least know it is one of the members because there are 8 members + a dot :\

[lyly_flower2000]

I just read about the controversy of this cartoon, well it depends on what everyone thinks.
As for me, well, it's kinda a little bit over limit. So I totally understand where the fans get the anger from but the author already apologized so just get over it.

[pinkmeetspurple]

isnt yuri and yoona interchanged again?... people would wonder who the dot is but let us leave it at that... plus the other stuff he drew or/and written.. so its understandable were the anger is coming from... but anyways the guy apologized already...

[yien_luvsoshi]

i saw this all over the place and it was top searched too..i was wondering..and now i know why.
Honestly it's not that bad, it's just a comic and someone's opinion. Well, at least a SNSD member gets recognized..so i'm fine with it. But i understand why sones got angry..

[BeLLisima]

i think the word "bad copies" and "a dot" the thing makes the fans angry
if he just leave the words behind i think the fans wont be angry

im angry but also laugh at the same time lol XD

[Jennyi_jc]

er seriously i dun get wat this mean at first..
after reading those replies below only i understood..
what they mean the 5 bad copies and a dot..
omgee..seriously..
it pissed the fans off..
even me..
but since he apologised..
well just get over it

[fallen.angel]

O__O
its not cute at all hah.
but the three girls he drew are sooyoung, yuri, and yoona
then the other "5 bad copies" <_<
he says are sunny, taeyeon, jessica, tiffany, hyoyoen, seohyun
i wonder whos the ball?

[cheesinator]

oh hell naw, he's discriminating against shorties. rotfl. anyway, i have a feeling the dot (scribble mark or wtv) is the shortest member.. and nowadays that's up for interpretations a well. (sun or tae... sun or tae?). well at least he didn't reveal who the scribbled dot member is.. that would've caused even more uproar. lol. thanks for sharing!

[Kanki]

The scribble can't be a member, that would make 10 girls in SNSD. What fans have to be mad about is the '5 bad copies' perhaps if he didn't write that it would be better. I can see how this would offend some SONEs, we should love all of the girls. But aside from that, his drawings are cute?

[belinda]

ohma...I see why it's such a big controversy...wow...5 bad ones..psh ^^
soshi fighting <3 I love all 9 of them keke ^^

[Kae-Chyi]

I saw this somewhere, and people were omg over it. I didn't understand it at all till now. And, it is disrespectful. It's nice that he says that he likes Yoona, Yuri, and Sooyoung, but he doesn't need to write "5 bad copies" and draw someone in a scribble. The drawing is cute though. But that's pretty mean to the other five girls. Oh well, I love all nine. :]] keke.

[goldenGAZE]

i think the word "bad copies" and "a dot" the thing makes the fans angry
if he just leave the words behind i think the fans wont be angry

im angry but also laugh at the same time lol XD

I agree. Its not nice to label the other girls as 'bad copies' plus one member is even a scribble ><. But i'll laugh it off as a joke since i know all the member are beautiful^^.